Saturday, December 8, 2012

Porters: Not Just the Other Dark Beer

It's fairly well known that porters preceded stouts.  In fact, "stout" was a descriptive used to describe porters, essentially meaning "strong," and eventually "stout porter" just became "stout."  Porters used to be fairly popular in the 18th and 19th centuries, until they eventually fell out of favor and were cast aside for the most part by breweries  (for a better, more comprehensive history on such things, check out the works of Randy Mosher and Garrett Oliver).  What we know of porters and stouts and what's popular now, it's hard to imagine a time when porters ruled.  It's hard to imagine porters as being anything other than an offshoot of more widely available stouts and not the other way around. 
A good question that I've always wondered is, what's the essential difference between a stout and a porter?  I don't have an answer, though a common one seems to be, stouts have roasted barley and porters don't.  But, apparently, this is not always the case.  For me, it's hard to pinpoint exactly what's different.  Perhaps a bit more of a burnt or toasty taste, and perhaps not as smooth or creamy, though not always.  There's a lot of overlap in the styles, and I'd venture to say that the defining line is rather fluid. 
Anyway, as I'm getting more in more into this beer thing, I'm experiencing more porters, and I'm finding some good ones.  Here are a few worth trying:

Smuttynose Robust Porter 
A bold tasting porter, worthy of being called "robust."  Flavors of chocolate, malt, coffee, licorice, caramel come through, along with smokiness, toastiness, and spiciness. Smooth and bursting with flavor. One of the better porters out there, particularly for the price. 

Founders Porter
Strong milk chocolate and coffee flavors at the front, with dark chocolate and toastiness following.  A good mixture of sweetness and bitterness.  This porter doesn't come across as flashy, but it excels at what it has.  For me, top of the list for porters.  Unfortunately, Founders is not distributed to Maryland. 

Kona Pipeline Porter
The first time I tried this porter was in October at the Epcot Food & Wine Festival in Disney World, where it stood out among the beer offerings. It's quite tasty and smooth with a nice coffee heavy profile that retains solid notes of a more traditional porter. 

Fuller's London Porter
Deep flavored porter that has a nice mellowness.  Creamy and consistent from start to finish.  A classic porter from one of the traditional English breweries.  In your porter discovery adventures, this is one you must try.

Others to try: Samuel Smith's The Famous Taddy Porter, Anchor Porter, Sierra Nevada Porter, Williamsburg Alewerks Washington's Porter, Evolution Lucky 7 Porter
My wish list: Ballast Point Victory at Sea Coffee Vanilla Imperial Porter, Harviestoun Old Engine Oil, Stone Smoked Porter, Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald, Port City Porter

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Review: Dogfish Head Olde School Barleywine (2011)

Dogfish Head Olde School Barleywine (2011 edition)
ABV:15.0%
Dogfish Head Craft Brewery, Milton, DE
12 oz bottle
Served in Dogfish Head Signature Glass
Date on bottle: Bottled in 2011 (purchased 10/2011; aged 1 year, 1 month)
Reviewed on 12/1/12 

This barleywine pours a hazy golden amber color with a thin bubbly off-white head with moderately good retention.  Not much carbonation. Good lacing.

On the nose, malt and alcohol are the upfront, dominant aromas.  Slight caramel, slight whiskey, slight grape-like fruitiness, with some hints of bread and yeast.

On the palate, malt, caramel, and alcohol are the dominant flavors coming through, with some whiskey and even some slight hops coming through more on the back end.  Mild notes of fruit.  Some sugariness coming through as well.

Mouthfeel is a bit harsh with the prevalent alcohol taste.  There's some decent bitterness, with a touch of dryness.  After some time and a few sips, a good smoothness emerges beneath the alcohol.

Overall, a quite strong, interesting barleywine that has some decent tastes beneath a hot alcohol taste at the front.  As far as my memory goes, this beer has mellowed a bit over the last year, and it would be interesting to see what it would be like after two years of aging.  Beyond the alcohol and malt flavors, caramel, whiskey, and some fruity notes come through and give it a neat and distinguishable profile.  A nice one to savor.  Nowhere near being sessionable (no surprise given the ABV).

Score: 92

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Review: Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale

Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale (2012 edition)
ABV: 6.8%
Sierra Nevada Brewing Co., Chico, CA
12 oz bottle
Served in Dogfish Head Signature Glass
Reviewed on 11/24/12 

This ale pours a dark amber color with a nice thick frothy head with good retention.  Moderate carbonation. Great lacing.

On the nose, notes of grapefruit, hops, malt, pine, slight floral, and other citrus, maybe a hint of lemon.

Taste has hops and malt, grapefruit, slight lemon, pine, some floral, hints of wheat and yeast.

Mouthfeel is dry and bitter in a good way yet with a fairly mellow feel on the palate.  Flavors are superbly balanced.

Overall, a quite tasty IPA that is both well hopped and well malted.  Great balance of flavors with a profile that comes across as a deep, earthy ale that, even as an IPA, fits well with the winter season.  A superb offering at a great price, showing yet again that you can get world class beers without destroying your budget.

Score: 95

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Review: Stillwater Artisanal Of Love & Regret


Stillwater Artisanal Of Love & Regret, Import Series Vol. 1
ABV: 7.2%
Belgian Saison Ale
11.2 oz btl
Served in Dogfish Head Signature Glass
Reviewed on 5/10/12

This ale pours a light brackish brown.  Thick off-white bubbly head that keeps.  Good lacing and carbonation.  Lots of particles floating around.  On the nose, there's a strong earthy-type smell, with some hops, lemon, herbs and spices, yeast. The taste is lemony, with a touch of spices and other citrus flavors.  It's fairly light tasting with earthiness.  Definite yeast.  As I got closer to the end, yeasty sediment took over and it became harder to drink.  The mouthfeel is grainy--I can feel the particles on the tongue.  Slightly thinner than expected.

When I opened the bottle, it pretty much exploded, something I wasn't prepared for.  It's definitely an interesting earthy-type beer, though as I continued drinking it, I liked it less and less.  Perhaps I poured it a bit too vigorously and allowed too much of the sediment to get into my glass.  Perhaps I picked up a bottle that had gone bad (I couldn't find a date on it).  Perhaps my palate's not ready for this one.  Anyway, I wasn't too fond of it, but I'd be willing to give it another go in the future.


Score: 78

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

A Slight Change to My Current Top Ten

I've had a slight change in the My Current Top Ten list, which hangs out in the right column of this page.  Ballast Point Sculpin IPA and Green Flash Palate Wrecker have switched places, mostly owing to Sculpin now being available in my area and Palate Wrecker being a seasonal that, well, hasn't wrecked my palate in quite a few months now because there's none to have.

Saturday, November 24, 2012

Review: Southern Tier Harvest Special Ale

Southern Tier Harvest Special Ale
Extra Special Bitter (ESB)
ABV: 6.7%
12 oz bottle
Served in Dogfish Head Signature Glass
Reviewed on 9/3/12 

This ale pours a nice amber color with a thin white head that quickly dissipates.  Mild carbonation and mild lacing present.  Not as lively as you might expect for a recently released, fresh beer.

Nose has malt, hops, citrus, hints of nutmeg and pumpkin, and a slight floral smell.  Taste reveals a bit more than the smell, with malt, hops, nutmeg, grapefruit, citrus, floral and even pumpkin notes coming with a hint of cinnamon.

Mouthfeel has some earthiness yet is smooth, slightly dry, and slightly bitter.  It presents a decent balance of flavors.  Slightly thin on the back end.

Overall, this has a good mix of decently balanced flavors that come together for a good autumn taste.  Hints of a pumpkin ale, and also suggests an IPA and even a brown ale.  Interesting profile, even if it might be a bit all over the place.  For me, it's not quite there but it's close.

Score: 88

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Dogfish Head Burton Baton: A Tale of Two Reviews

For its Burton Baton, Dogfish Head says, "we brew two 'threads,' or batches, of beer: an English-style old ale and an imperial IPA."  The number two is fitting, as I have two reviews for Burton Baton.  Back in February 2012, I purchased a four-pack of Burton Baton that, according to the stamped date, was bottled on November 28, 2011.  So, before my first review on April 21, I had already had two of them; after the first review, I decided to hang on to the last one for a bit longer and review it again, which ended up being on June 2.  The April 21 review was almost at the five month point, and the June 2 review was just beyond the six month point.  As you can see in the latter review, the beer has definitely changed in terms of its flavor profile, as the maltiness has become more dominant.

I should note that my aging process, if you can even call it that, is fairly primitive.  I keep beers in a box or an unused cooler, stored upright, in my basement, doing my best to preserve them from light and temperature changes.  Maybe one day I'll work up to something a little more formal like a special refrigerator or other temperature controlled area. 

Dogfish Head Burton Baton
ABV:10%
12 oz bottle
Served in Dogfish Head Signature Glass
Bottled on 11/28/11 

4/21/12 review (5 months) 

Pours an orangish amber with a thin bubbly head that quickly dissipates.  Good carbonation showing.  The beer is opaque and somewhat cloudy.  Minimal lacing.

Smell consists of vanilla and oak, sweetness with a touch of honey, touch of spice, the slight aroma of a fine liquor.

Taste has dominant flavors of vanilla and oak.  Malt, some hoppiness, somewhat bitter on the back end.  Alcohol taste comes through but not overly strong.

Mouthfeel is smooth with some earthiness.  Has a good balance of flavors with a good balance of bitterness and the feel of a fine whiskey.

Overall, this beer has a good complex mix of tastes, coming across as bold and unique.  A beer that's big and demands to be savored.  Pricey but superior.

Score: 97


6/2/12 review (6 months)

Pours a cloudy orangish-amber with a thin bubbly head that quickly dissipates.  Mild carbonation.  Mild lacing.

Smell consists of malt, vanilla, oak, bit of an alcohol/liquor note, faint spice and sweetness.

Taste has malt and some chocolate notes coming through.  Touch of vanilla.  Touch of spice.  Fading hops.

Mouthfeel is smooth with an earthy feel, and there's almost a chewiness coming through.  Dryness on the back end.  Fading bitterness.

Overall, this beer still has a good complex mix of flavors, though it has definitely changed since the 4/21/12 review.  The flavor profile seems to be moving more toward that of a stout, as the malty notes are more prevalent.  It still has a definite alcohol taste.  It's perhaps easier to drink than it was the last time.

Score: 97